Sharing Lungs - Deftones Online Community

Music => Music General Discussion => Topic started by: skinnypuppy on Nov 23, 2008, 09:40 AM

Title: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: skinnypuppy on Nov 23, 2008, 09:40 AM
It's been a decade, who do you think Refused is most proud of?

Poison the Well
Bring Me the Horizon
Suicide Silence
Architects
SOME GIRLS
United Nations
The Mistake
Converge
American Nightmare
Narrows
Trap Them
Glassjaw
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Jedidiah Solomon on Nov 23, 2008, 04:23 PM
I've only got a thousand words to say to you

BAD MUTHA FUCKIN' BRAINS
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: devlin on Nov 23, 2008, 04:43 PM
The (International) Noise Conspiracy :)
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: defskull on Nov 23, 2008, 07:56 PM
Dillinger Escape Plan
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: bright lights, big city on Nov 23, 2008, 10:03 PM
i'd say either Poison the Well or Dillinger Escape Plan

but damn, I gotta listen to that album again, its been too long
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: skinnypuppy on Nov 24, 2008, 06:42 AM
Quote from: Jedidiah Solomon on Nov 23, 2008, 04:23 PM
I've only got a thousand words to say to you

BAD MUTHA FUCKIN' BRAINS

Nah, doesn't count haha. You fail. bad brians helped creat punk, and then a decade later Refused fucked with it... now, a decade from then, we're left wondering, what came?

I think the punk scene was let down after 'the shape of punk to come' - I think Denis let himself down with T(I)NC. United Nations gave me the idea for this thread with the track "the shape of punk that never came" and while I agree for the most part with the track title, I think Refused did pave the way for some stellar music. I know Refused are proud of PTW, considering they produced Versions...

DEP is a great example of the punk that came. I agree completely.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: indychinoluv on Nov 25, 2008, 12:14 AM
Quote from: skinnypuppy on Nov 24, 2008, 06:42 AM
Quote from: Jedidiah Solomon on Nov 23, 2008, 04:23 PM
I've only got a thousand words to say to you

BAD MUTHA FUCKIN' BRAINS

Nah, doesn't count haha. You fail. bad brians helped creat punk, and then a decade later Refused fucked with it... now, a decade from then, we're left wondering, what came?

I think the punk scene was let down after 'the shape of punk to come' - I think Denis let himself down with T(I)NC. United Nations gave me the idea for this thread with the track "the shape of punk that never came" and while I agree for the most part with the track title, I think Refused did pave the way for some stellar music. I know Refused are proud of PTW, considering they produced Versions...

DEP is a great example of the punk that came. I agree completely.

Cool post dude. I've always thought of DEP as a metal band.

United Nations dissapointed me
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Paint Your Lips on Nov 25, 2008, 01:49 PM
Quote from: indychinoluv on Nov 25, 2008, 12:14 AM
United Nations dissapointed me
Yeah, everyone should lsten to Orchid or Ampere instead.

First of all, what a weird list. Secondly, I think we have to look at the bands that are equally innovative as Refused was on "The Shape of Punk to come". To me, the band that has improved and renewed the genre the most is clearly Poison the Well. They continue to renew and alter their sound and blend punk with a lot of other genres and add a lot of instruments not heard in punk before.

My two cents.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Alvar on Nov 25, 2008, 02:59 PM
genghis tron

or does that already count as the punk that came after the punk that came after the punk....
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: alvarezbassist17 on Nov 25, 2008, 04:40 PM
oh man, this is hard.  I'd say poison the well is like the best reflection of the style that refused were trying to proliferate, but i dunno, there's other good bands like underoath (flame me if you want, they've put out some good cds) or rise against, protest the hero, misery signals (who i don't really enjoy, but they definitely employ that sort of style), the fall of troy, fear before the march of flames, and every time i die, among many others.  but then you have the further reaches, bands like DEP and converge. 

the world of music definitely could have sucked if it weren't for their conversion of punk into heaviness, and the consequent rise of hardcore and its offshoots (deathcore, yummy)
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: bright lights, big city on Nov 25, 2008, 05:46 PM
mmm yea deathcore is likely my new favorite genre
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: deepest_ocean on Nov 25, 2008, 10:59 PM
by the way anyone seen the documentary made of refused? I can't remember the name of that anymore, it's not really that special but if you like them maby you should check it out.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: skinnypuppy on Nov 26, 2008, 12:29 AM
Refused Are Fucking Dead - DVD
orgasm in my mouth. I love the DVD. it explains all the shit that happened to the band.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Deftones-argentina on Nov 27, 2008, 07:06 PM
In my oppinion that is a little too overexaggerated. I can understand that pressions can get big with 4 or 5 people 24/7 together with things like labels and things like being annoying and so on, but come on, they made it look like they were the survivors of the Titanic...

With that said, I like refused.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: skinnypuppy on Dec 01, 2008, 10:51 PM
I don't really feel as if they are the ones stating they changed punk, but rather everyone else saying it, and them accepting it.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: ben on Dec 03, 2008, 06:09 PM
They haven't influenced anyone, because no one else has made a record like them.  Most of the album isn't even hardcore, it's just punk/jazz with a lot of cultural influences.  Poison the Well sounding like Refused?  They just record albums in the same place.

but with that said, if you are saying they have influenced people, they have done nothing but to make a horrible wave of shitty bands. 

Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: ronnie dobbs on Dec 03, 2008, 09:52 PM
Quote from: ben on Dec 03, 2008, 06:09 PM
They haven't influenced anyone, because no one else has made a record like them.  Most of the album isn't even hardcore, it's just punk/jazz with a lot of cultural influences.  Poison the Well sounding like Refused?  They just record albums in the same place.

but with that said, if you are saying they have influenced people, they have done nothing but to make a horrible wave of shitty bands. 



That is pretty much happens when any true infuential bands appear, a thousand shitty clones.

Here are the liner notes for the CD. Each song title is in italics, and instead of the lyrics, there is the meaning to every song. This CD deserves all the praise it gets.

01. Worms Of The Senses / Faculties Of The Skull
02. Liberation Frequency
03. The Deadly Rythm
04. Summer Holidays Vs. Punkroutine
05. Bruitist Pome #5
06. New Noise
07. The Refused Party Program
08. Protest Song '68
09. Refused Are Fuckin Dead
10. The Shape Of Punk To Come
11. Tannh䵳er / Deriv耼/p>
12. The Apollo Programme Was A Hoax

http://www.burningheart.com/refused/refmanifest1.htm (http://www.burningheart.com/refused/refmanifest1.htm)
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: No More Sugar on May 04, 2009, 02:59 AM
dennis lyxzen is a failure.
the world couldn't control what Refused created..
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 02:20 AM
I don't know who these bands are, alls I know is the best Rock n Roll band that ever came was the Bad Brains, the best punk band that ever came was the bad brains, the best hardcore band that ever came was the bad brains, the best alternative band that ever played was the bad brains, one of the best metal bands that ever played was the bad brains and one of the best reggae bands that ever played was the bad brains.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: No More Sugar on May 06, 2009, 02:32 AM
Quote from: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 02:20 AM
I don't know who these bands are, alls I know is Bad Brains is one of the most influential bands in punk.

fix'd.

if you don't like the feel of the post hardcore movement and whatever name you have for the style of music popular with scene kids so aptly named "Hardcore"(when honestly, it's not true to the word Hardcore whatsoever in my opinion) you won't like any of those bands.(EXCEPT GLASSJAW, as GJ is one of those bands that I would actually call Hardcore, as they stuck to the book.). I'll also note that these days, in that specific "category" of music, the lines seperating hardcore, Metalcore, grindcore, and Death Metal have all been erased and fused into a genre filled with shitty music that resulted from a failed experiment called Post Hardcore generally believed to be started with Fugazi, but was brought to mainstream by none other than the punk band Refused.

United Nations is amazing...possibly one of the only almost "grind" bands I like. I also enjoy The Locust.

Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 02:38 AM
Naw you didn't fix that quote, you just ruined it and said the same thing everyone else says cause they don't know, the importance of the bad brains to modern music cannot be overstated, I'm not even talking about "hardcore" music or "Punk" they were so much more than that quote you "fixed." they revolutionized Rock N Roll music as a whole completley and created alternative music, what is more alternative then crazy fast, vursiostic rock music with straight roots reggae? and that's not where it stops, every album after that was experimentation with every other genre of music, especially H.R.'s other group. anyway I ain't got nothin against any of these bands, much respect to them, I'm just saying the importance of the brains can never be overstated to really any modern contemporary genre.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: No More Sugar on May 06, 2009, 02:41 AM
Quote from: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 02:38 AM
Naw you didn't fix that quote, you just ruined it and said the same thing everyone else says cause they don't know, the importance of the bad brains to modern music cannot be overstated, I'm not even talking about "hardcore" music or "Punk" they were so much more than that quote you "fixed." they revolutionized Rock N Roll music as a whole completley and created alternative music, what is more alternative then crazy fast, vursiostic rock music with straight roots reggae? and that's not where it stops, every album after that was experimentation with every other genre of music, especially H.R.'s other group. anyway I ain't got nothin against any of these bands, much respect to them, I'm just saying the importance of the brains can never be overstated to really any modern contemporary genre.

Thanks for the history lesson. I'm aware of this.

"Bad Brains is one of the most influential bands in Rock"

Happy?
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 02:44 AM
no

"The Bad Brains are the most revolutionary american musicians, ever."
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: No More Sugar on May 06, 2009, 03:40 AM
Quote from: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 02:44 AM
no

"The Bad Brains are the most revolutionary american musicians, ever."

Not nearly as revolutionary as The Beatles...or Black Sabbath...
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 03:42 AM
ha all rite, actually they were, alls the beatles did was rip off chuck berry riffs, but so did everybody, black sabbath added a couple notches more gain to it, shit even the brains had some chuck berry riffage, whatever its all good, I got respect for all bands doin their thing if they got respect for what their doin.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: No More Sugar on May 06, 2009, 03:49 AM
don't get me wrong i'm not demeaning bad brains, they are classic, but there were other bands/people that did more for rock before the brains even came out
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: Earthman on May 06, 2009, 03:54 AM
yeah, I luv all those bands too, without being prejudice, they are definitley more important than led zeppelin and sabbath, and ozzy and sabbath was my first favorite shit. Why are they? because you had Chuck berry and the creation of modern rock so called, and alot of things happened in between, great things, but nothin really changed that much until '78, '79. Then shit got wild, and bands like black flag and so on were being born, un heard of shit, and black rastas playing punk, that shit is still mystical. anyway, its all good man. all these bands are good so its okay, fuck the politics.
Title: Re: The shape of punk that came...
Post by: No More Sugar on May 06, 2009, 04:09 AM
that i can very much agree with.

my whole theory recently is:

the deftones have been the leaders...the biggest of the underground bands.
and basically why I have really been getting into music, is to continue this minuscule "revolution" in "rock...metal....post hardcore.....essentially, punk."

i used to listen to all the new shit...the hardcore...the screamo, death metal...all of that shit. Then i got bored with all of that because it sounds pretty much the same, and I began to retrace my steps and get back to my roots. I began to listen to bands I had known of for many years(DT, Refused, Glassjaw, Quicksand, Far), but never really listened to as much because I was clouded by all the new more "jumpy" music. Then I went back even further and started digging up old metal bands such as Flaw and Korn...the new metal, and of course all the music my father showed me which was all even older...zappa, zepplin, tommy bolin, alvin lee, the james gang, i mean i could go on.

but essentially, the band i'm planning on starting is going to be a composite mix of all the influence i've ever had, and i've had a LOT of influence.